ART- I think we get that from the quick "hate its" and "love its" we always get from people on here. If I'm looking to see what people simply think I get that from those type of comments. What I would value from an assesment on concept and craft is a select group like you, kozik, jeff, and maybe even some of the newer people who are starting up succesful practices under today's challenges, to make the assesment. Maybe that's just me.
But like any assesment a scale or a grade you need someone or a select few to hand out the assesment. For everyone to do it you will end up with the the color brown everytime, because at different levels of talent and experience "the bar" changes and so would the scale. So who is to be the teacher or teachers?
I really want to read something into this one I keep looking at it hoping that I see something..... it kind of looks like the famous photo of bigfoot walking in the forest.... does anyone else see that?