Oh, I'm not too into number assigning, I don't think. The whole "rate that girl on a scale of 1-10" thing i was never really good at, as I would constantly shift my criteria and never arrive at a satisfactory conclusion. I'm going to stick with the more generalized
I think I would place the concept a little lower and the craft a little higher. I think the image is essentially clipart (whether they drew it or not) in terms of it bearing no relation to the band or the music. This could easily be a Nashville Pussy poster or a Marilyn Manson poster. That sort of thing turns me off a bit. Not that I'm very good at it myself.
As far as craft, I like that the bottom info was left intentionally quite bland - somewhat reminiscent of the publisher info on a 50's-60's comic book cover, but not in an overly-mimicking way (at least as far as I know).